Top Summerland Key Hotels for a Blissful Stay

We checked thousands of reviews on and to find the best hotels for your stay
Go to Hotel List View map

Katerina Kore

Updated: 02 January 2024 · 2 min

Nestled in the very heart of the Florida Keys, Summerland Key offers an escape into paradise for travelers seeking tranquility and beauty in equal measure. This island, a hidden jewel among the keys, is renowned for its crystal-clear waters, breathtaking sunsets, and lush tropical surroundings. For those looking to immerse themselves in this serene environment, finding the perfect hotel in Summerland Key is the first step toward a dream vacation.

Choosing the right accommodation can elevate your experience, turning a simple getaway into an unforgettable adventure. Hotels in Summerland Key are diverse, catering to a wide range of preferences and budgets. Whether you're in search of a luxurious resort equipped with all the modern amenities or a cozy, intimate hotel that offers a more personal touch, Summerland Key has something unique to offer. Each hotel promises its guests a comfortable stay, scenic views, and easy access to the island’s attractions.

Insights into the best Summerland Key hotels can guide travelers in making an informed decision. From waterfront hotels offering direct beach access to those tucked away amidst the island’s lush greenery, there’s an accommodation for every kind of traveler. Recommendations often highlight the importance of considering location, amenities, and guest reviews when selecting a hotel, ensuring your stay in Summerland Key not only meets but exceeds your expectations.
Show more + Show less -

Our Top 4

(Sorted by rating & number of reviews)

1. Waterfront Anchor House With Boat Basin & Ramp Villa
2. Sun Outdoors Sugarloaf Key Villa
3. Private Estate Pool Ocean View 20 Minutes To Key West Villa
4. Looe Key Reef Resort And Dive Center

Best Dive Resorts - Summerland Key Hotels

Check Availability

Summerland Key
Mar 23, 2026 - Mar 24, 2026

Waterfront Anchor House With Boat Basin & Ramp Villa

+ 15 photos
Situated directly on the water, Waterfront Anchor House with Boat Basin & Ramp is an adventurer’s dream. This property not only offers guests their private boat ramp and basin but also easy access to some of the best fishing and water sports locations in the Florida Keys. The house is fully equipped for comfort and convenience, allowing guests to focus on their outdoor pursuits. With ample space for gear storage and an ideal setting for barbecue evenings after a day on the water, the Anchor House makes a perfect base for those looking to explore the natural beauty and excitement of Summerland Key. Its waterfront location ensures that adventure is always just steps away.
Address: 373 Barry Avenue

Family-friendly Retreats - Summerland Key Hotels

When planning a family vacation, finding accommodations that cater to the needs of both adults and children is crucial. In Summerland Key, several hotels are designed with families in mind, offering spacious accommodations, kid-friendly amenities, and activities that everyone can enjoy. These family-friendly retreats provide the perfect blend of relaxation for parents and fun for kids, ensuring a memorable stay for all. From private beach access to pools and outdoor recreational activities, each hotel in this section promises a delightful escape for families looking to enjoy the natural beauty and tranquility of Summerland Key.

Sun Outdoors Sugarloaf Key Villa

9.2

Good

(21 Reviews)

+ 28 photos
Sun Outdoors Sugarloaf Key is an ideal destination for families vacationing in the Florida Keys. Offering a variety of accommodations from RV sites to charming cottages, the resort caters to different family sizes and preferences. With a focus on outdoor living, it features a sparkling pool, a marina for boating enthusiasts, and easy access to kayaking and paddleboarding adventures. The on-site restaurant ensures that dining is convenient, while the planned activities keep the younger guests entertained. Sun Outdoors Sugarloaf Key creates a welcoming environment where families can reconnect and create lasting memories amidst the beauty of Summerland Key.
Address: 3000 Johnson Road
Rating: Good 9.2 (21 Reviews)
Rooms: 19
Price: From 249$

Romantic Hideaways - Summerland Key Hotels

For couples seeking a romantic getaway, Summerland Key offers secluded hotels that promise privacy, luxury, and unforgettable experiences. These romantic hideaways are perfect for honeymoons, anniversaries, or simply a peaceful escape with your loved one. Guests can expect personalized service, serene surroundings, and special touches like private dinners by sunset or couples massages. Each hotel in this section has been chosen for its romantic ambiance, breathtaking views, and ability to create a sense of intimacy and connection, making them the ultimate choice for couples looking to celebrate their love in Summerland Key.

Private Estate Pool Ocean View 20 Minutes To Key West Villa

+ 52 photos
The Private Estate Pool Ocean View offers an unparalleled luxury experience, situated just a short drive from the heart of Key West. This exclusive property features a stunning oceanfront pool, elegantly designed interiors, and expansive outdoor areas ideal for relaxation or entertainment. Guests will be captivated by the panoramic views of the Atlantic Ocean, making every sunrise and sunset an event to remember. The estate offers complete privacy and seclusion, along with high-end amenities and a fully equipped kitchen, ensuring a stay that epitomizes luxury island living. This estate exemplifies the opulence that discerning travelers can find in Summerland Key.
Address: 124 Colson Drive

Luxurious Getaways - Summerland Key Hotels

For the discerning traveler seeking an upscale experience in Summerland Key, the area boasts hotels that combine luxury with the natural glamour of the Florida Keys. These establishments are characterized by exceptional service, elegant accommodations, and exclusive amenities designed to pamper and impress. Guests can expect to find gourmet dining options, spa services, and rooms with breathtaking views that elevate every moment of their stay. Each hotel selected under this theme offers a unique blend of comfort, elegance, and access to the rich natural beauty of the Keys, making them perfect for a lavish retreat.

Looe Key Reef Resort And Dive Center

7.0

Good

(583 Reviews)

+ 44 photos
Looe Key Reef Resort and Dive Center is a haven for divers looking to explore the vibrant underwater ecosystems of the Florida Keys. This resort not only offers easy access to the famous Looe Key National Marine Sanctuary but also features an on-site dive center equipped with rental gear and boats ready to take you on your next underwater adventure. With comfortable, nautically themed rooms, an inviting pool area, and a lively tiki bar, guests can relax after a day of diving. The resort's dive packages cater to both beginners and certified divers, ensuring every guest has the opportunity to experience the magic of the reef. Looe Key Reef Resort and Dive Center truly embodies the spirit of adventure that attracts visitors to Summerland Key hotels.
Address: 27340 Overseas Highway
Rating: Good 7.0 (583 Reviews)
Rooms: 23
Price: From 100$

Adventure and Outdoor Activities - Summerland Key Hotels

Adventure seekers and outdoor enthusiasts will find Summerland Key an ideal destination, with hotels that provide easy access to a myriad of activities from fishing and kayaking to snorkeling and eco-tours. These accommodations are not just places to stay but gateways to experiencing the thrilling adventures the Keys have to offer. Guests can look forward to comfortable stays that cater to their adventurous spirit, including facilities for storing gear, organizing excursions, and providing expert advice on local spots. The hotels highlighted in this section are chosen for their commitment to offering an immersive outdoor experience, ensuring every guest can make the most of their visit to Summerland Key.